Bobby Fish embarked on his professional wrestling career in 2002, quickly establishing himself with technical prowess and strategic in-ring performances. He made his debut for Ring of Honor (ROH) on October 2, 2004, before joining Pro Wrestling Unplugged in February 2005. There, he formed a successful tag team with Scott Cardinal, capturing the vacant PWU Tag Team Championship in May 2005. Fish also showcased his combat sports versatility by making his amateur kickboxing debut on January 29, 2010, for the Cage Wars organization in Albany, New York, securing a TKO victory over Justin Pierpoint in the third round.
Fish’s career gained significant international recognition starting in 2006 with his first tour of Japan for Pro Wrestling Noah, debuting on May 19, 2006, against Atsushi Aoki. He continued to tour annually with Noah until 2013, participating in notable tournaments such as the 2011 Global League and the 2012 NTV G Cup Junior Heavyweight League. A pivotal moment occurred with his return to Ring of Honor in 2012, where he formed the highly acclaimed tag team ‘reDRagon’ with Kyle O’Reilly. This partnership led to three reigns as ROH World Tag Team Champions between 2013 and 2015, a Super Jr.
He made his debut for All Elite Wrestling (AEW) in October 2021, reuniting with former partners Adam Cole and Kyle O’Reilly. Fish then appeared in Impact Wrestling in September 2022 and returned to NJPW Strong in November 2022, aligning himself with Team Filthy. His sustained presence in prominent organizations and consistent championship pursuits underscore his enduring career in professional wrestling.